Levelling the playing field in construction: International Women’s Day

Even with a database as large as Safety Diagnostics, with more than 50,000 individual cases, producing robust data on women in the construction industry is challenging.

Women comprise around 12% of our survey population, drawn from tier one contractors and major projects across the UK and Ireland, that’s around 6,000 women to c 42,000 men.  The problem, however, isn’t just one of scale. Men and women tend to work in different environments  in the construction industry, with men far more likely to be site or partly site-based, with women more likely to be office based.  They also undertake different roles with women far less likely to be engaged in production oriented roles than men. So asking the whole population their views on risk, on mental health, on culture and then analysing on the basis of gender produces polarised views based on very different working experiences, by and large.

Drilling down into the data however and weighting to compensate for these differences produces some concerning findings.  When compared on a like for like basis, women working in a production environment (site or site/office environment) are twice as likely as their office only sisters and three times as likely as men to report witnessing or experiencing bullying or harassment.  This suggests that the production environment is still fairly hostile to women.

The dataset of women in management roles is even smaller – fewer than 2% of the respondents in the database report that they are both women and managers.  Respondents this group of less than one thousand cases are far more likely to report themselves at high risk of stress than their male colleagues (63% to 38%).

When the gender question is asked in our surveys, a small proportion of respondents refuse to answer. Anecdotally, we know that women are reluctant to identify as such because of concerns that their anonymity might be compromised and colleagues or bosses might be able to connect them with their responses. In reality this cannot happen as the analysis will never reveal that level of granularity and no-one outside Safety Diagnostics has access to the dataset.  But the anxiety that women feel about being singled out in the workplace is real enough, and perhaps reflects that more work needs to be done to make construction a level playing field for men and women.

Judging by our data alone, however, strides have already been made by the industry in the past decade.  The proportion of women in our surveys has risen from 10% of the population to 12% in five years and the proportion of women identifying as engineers, supervisors or managers has increased by 30%. Progress, perhaps, but still much further to go.

 

Updates

Safety is Viral!

Posted - 22. Mar .17

How peer pressure can influence safety attitudes and behaviour   A key attitude statement that is ranked in all Safety Diagnostics attitude survey is “Peer pressure sometimes makes me do…Read More

Safety Diagnostics as a Leading Measure for Construction Safety Planning

Posted - 17. Feb .16

How do you target limited resources to achieve a real improvement in safety performance?  Construction safety planning is often based on rear view mirror thinking. What has gone wrong in…Read More

Young Turks and Old Turkeys: Age Related Risk

Posted - 14. Apr .15

One of the most significant correlations that emerges from the Safety Diagnostics data is the link that exists between the age of respondents and attitudes to safety behaviour and risk.…Read More

Why Parents Matter

Posted - 18. Mar .15

Each Safety Diagnostics survey includes a question in the demographic section that asks respondents whether they are a parent.   This question often draws a suspicious response – ’Is this an…Read More

Why use focus groups in a climate survey?

Posted - 18. Feb .15

Most managers are familiar with climate surveys conducted using a questionnaire, either online or in paper copy. This is an efficient way of collecting information from across the workforce and…Read More

OUR CLIENTS

Process

Every Safety Diagnostics survey is tailored to suit the needs of individual businesses, reflecting the unique risk environment, safety culture and structure. Initial qualitative work is undertaken at the outset of the survey process in order to develop a research tool that accurately reflects the workforce structure and the risks they face. This initial research phase is undertaken once only and is not repeated on subsequent iterations of the survey.

Surveys

Safety Diagnostics will help you to create a safer workplace by developing an understanding of your team culture and mind-set.

Using a tailored site-based survey procedure, Safety Diagnostics measures attitudes to safety procedures, personal behaviour, team beliefs and safety values among your workforce, both directly employed and subcontracted. Surveys are conducted as a census so that everyone has the opportunity to give feedback through the system. The process is anonymous and the survey is analysed independently.

Find Out More

Benefits

Safety Diagnostics surveys provide a leading measure of safety behaviour. Gain detailed analysis of your workforce with targeted action points to improve behavioural safety goals. Measure the effectiveness of your safety initiatives through a confidential, independent and evidence based process.

Find Out More

Updates

08/03/19 - Levelling the playing field in construction: International Women’s Day

Even with a database as large as Safety Diagnostics, with more than 50,000 individual cases, producing robust data on women ...Read More

22/03/17 - Safety is Viral!

How peer pressure can influence safety attitudes and behaviour   A key attitude statement that is ranked in all Safety ...Read More

17/02/16 - Safety Diagnostics as a Leading Measure for Construction Safety Planning

How do you target limited resources to achieve a real improvement in safety performance?  Construction safety planning is often based ...Read More

14/04/15 - Young Turks and Old Turkeys: Age Related Risk

One of the most significant correlations that emerges from the Safety Diagnostics data is the link that exists between the ...Read More